|
azinorum -> RE: salam alekum (11/24/2006 5:56:06 PM)
|
My dear Lucifer, are you attempting to use sarcasm to explain your opinion??? Well I commend you for attempting to do so as this site needs an injection of humour, especially with all the anger and dissatisfaction that I see in most of the posts. However you just might have bitten off more than you can chew this time. Nice try but no cigar. I am an Iraqi, living and working in Baghdad which judging by some of the comments you are posting is more than you can claim to be (no disrespect OK!). It’s normally yanks that accuse me of being non Iraqi because of my English, although I wouldn’t dare to accuse you of being one of “our true leaders”. Again in time, once the US leaves Iraq much like they did in Vietnam and just about every other country they invaded in the 21st century, I would suggest that you look to our neighbors to the east who have positioned themselves perfectly to exert the principal long term influence on our culture and political preference (you know, that big country, population approx 80 million, language Persian, 8 years war etc, etc). In case you haven’t noticed Iraq is headed for a bloody civil war which will make what’s happening now look like a friendly game between Al Zawra and Al Talaba (these are 2 Iraqi football teams, but I’m sure you knew that already). I certainly don’t advocate dictatorships but each country has its different stages of development. What you fail to recognize about Iraqis is that we are not equipped to handle democracy. Nor is any other Arab state. For a democracy to work in Iraq you would first have to insure that it doesn’t fragment into separate states and without a strong leader this is inevitable. Democracy cannot be implemented by force. It might work in a small country like Kosovo but not in a country of Iraq’s vast cultural and religious divide. I was lucky enough to receive my education in the UK (a small modicum of IQ was required to complete my studies) before returning to my country and saw first hand how wonderful a living, working democracy can be but I recognized what you appear to have totally overlooked; it took hundreds of years for this system to be established and no matter how much you wish it to happen it will not do so in an Arab country. The 65% Iraqi majority you are referring to are uneducated and will always be ready to follow the cult of personality; hence Muqtada Al Sadr has such a fanatical following. This is a man who can barely string 2 sentences together in his native language let alone grasp the macro economical complexities of a working democratic system. You should be aware that the people that you see following him around like puppy dogs are the same people that used to dance like monkeys for Saddam. Who says "democracy" is best for all people? This form of political manifest destiny will have serious repercussions in years to come. The US are starting to realize this now and it won’t take long for them to flee with their tails between their legs and revert to buying their way in with the next dictator, who ever that may be, God help us. Iraq will become another Islamic state and do you really think that’s what’s best for Iraqis? This war, started under false pretenses by the Bush administration, will only cement that fact. The Islamic influence will never permit even partial democracy and I say this as a Muslim. Nothing can be done to create a stable democracy in Iraq. Iraq is an invented place, created by treaty between European imperial powers at the end of the 19th Century. The three major groups in Iraq, the Sunni, Shia, and Kurds have been enemies for hundreds of years. The only way to get them to live under one roof, so to speak, was to have a strong man like Saddam. Once the influence of a dictator is gone, these three groups will not willingly live together. This is plain to see for even the less enlightened amongst us. For a country like ours to achieve democracy we would have to go through hundreds of years of social, political, cultural, economic, diplomatic, revolutionary and constitutional change. The only thing this Genie that was forced out of his bottle can bring is years of civil war, millions of lost lives and the end result will be the same. Another dictator. Is this what you think the people of Iraq want?. Just think about it. Regards. Azinorum
|
|
|
|